This book studies the logic of pollution control behavior of municipal governments by taking the industrial pollution control expenditure of key cities as an indicator, and finds that the pollution control expenditure does not show a normal distribution and gradual growth, but shows a "intermittent equilibrium" characteristic. Existing theories are not sufficient to explain these phenomena, and this book proposes a more explanatory analytical framework - "institutional structure and policymakers' attention". First, the resistance to the decision-making process and the limitation of the attention of decision-makers constitute institutional structural factors, which make the change of governance expenditure stagnate or fine-tune for a long time, so that environmental issues are not paid attention and attention to by policymakers. Second, policymakers' attention to environmental protection has led to more intermittent and larger than expected increases in pollution control spending by municipal governments. This book argues that the drivers of decision-makers' attention shift and institutional structural factors compete with each other to influence pollution control behavior.(AI翻译)
彭铭刚:(著)
彭铭刚,1985年2月出生,本科毕业于中山大学政治与公共事务学院,博士毕业于香港中文大学政治与行政学系,公共管理博士。现为广州大学公共管理学院政治管理系讲师。长期关注于中国地方政府的环境治理、应对气候变化行为以及环境财政等方面。现主持教育部人文社科青年项目“间断均衡式治理:地方政府环境治理的逻辑”以及广东省教育厅项目“资源禀赋与中国地方治理研究”。并在Politics、Journal of East Asian Studies、《中南大学学报(社会科学版)》等国内外知名刊物发表论文近十篇。
英文文献
[1]Arthur,Jeffrey,“ The Link between business strategy and industrial relations systems in American Steel Minimills” ,Industrial and Labor Relations Review,1992,45:488-506.
[2]Bachrach,Peter and Morton Baratz,“ Two Faces of Power” ,American Politi cal Science Review,1962,56(4):947-952.
[3]Bailey,J.and O' Connor,R.,“ Operationalizing Incrementalism: Measuring the muddles” ,Public Administration Review,1975,35:60-66.
[4]Bak,Per,How Nature Works,New York: Springer-Verlag,1997.
[5]Baumgartner Frank and Bryan D.Jones,“ Agendas Dynamics and Policy Subsystems” ,Journal of Politics,1991,53(4):1044-1074.
[6]Baumgartner,Frank R.et al.,“ Punctuated Equilibrium in Comparative Perspective” ,American Journal of Politi cal Science,2009,53(3):603–620.
[7]Baumgartner R.Frank and Bryan D.Jones,Agendas and Instability in American Politics,Chicago: The University of Chicago Press,2009.
[8]Berlyne,D.E.,“ Attention” ,in Edward C.Carterette and Morton P.Friedman,eds.,Handbook of Perception,New York: McGraw-Hill,1974.
[9]Bish ,Robert,The Public Economy of Metropolitan Areas,Chicago:Markham,1973.
[10]Bo,Zhiyue,“ Eonomic Performance and Politi cal Mobility: Chinese Provincial Leaders” ,Journal of Contemporary China,1996,5(12):135-155.
[11]Bo Zhiyue,Chinese Provincial Leaders: Economic Performance and Politi cal Mobility since 1949,Armonk,N.Y.: M.E.Sharpe,2002.
[12]Breuning,C.and Koski,C.,“ Punctuated Equilibria and Budgets in American States” ,The Policy Studies Journal,2006,34(30):3636-3679.
[13]Buchanan,James M.and Gordon Tullock,The Calculus of Consent,Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press,1962.
[14]Bunce,Valerie,Subversive Institutions: The Design and the Destruction of Socialism and the State,Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,1999.
[15]Chen,Ye,et al.,“ Relative Performance Evaluation and the Turnover of Provincial Leaders in China” ,Economic Letters,2005,88:421-425
[16]Child,John,Yuan Lu and Terence Tsai,“ Institutional Entrepreneurship in Building an Environmental Protection System for the People's Republic of China” ,Organization Studies,2007,28(7):1013-1034.
[17]Clark,Pand J.Wilson,“ Incentive System: A Theory of Organizations” ,Administrative Science Quarterly,1961,6(3):129-166.
[18]Crow,Deserai Anderson,“ Lo cal Media and Experts: Sources of Environmental Policy Initiation?” ,Policy Studies Journal,2010,38(1): 143-164.
[19]Davis,O.A.,Dempster,M.A.H.and Wildavsky,A.,“ A Theory of the Budgetary Process” ,The American Politi cal Science Review,1966,4(3):529-549.
[20]Dasgupta,Susmita and David Wheeler,“ Citizen Complaints as Environmental Indicators: Evidence from China” ,Policy Research Working Paper Series,1704,1997.
[21]Easterly,William,The Elusive Quest for Growth: Economists' Adventures and Misadventures in the Tropics,The MIT Press,2002.
[22]Economy,C.Elizabeth,The River Runs Black: The Environmental Challenge to China' s Future,Cornell University Press,2010.
[23]Eldridge,Nile and Gould,Stephen J.,“ Punctuated equilibria: an alternative to phyletic gradualism” ; in Schopf,Thomas J.M.eds.,Models in Paleobiology,San Francisco: Freeman Copper,1972,p.82-115.
[24]Feuerwerker,A.,R.Murphey and M.Wright,Approaches to Modern Chinese History,Berkeley: University of California Press,1967.
[25]Gould,Stephen J.,The Structure of Evolution Theory,Cambridge,MA: Belknap Press,2002.
[26]GuoGang,“ China' s Lo cal Politi cal Budget Cycles” ,American Journal of Politi cal Science,2009,53(3):623.
[27]Heberer,Thomas and Senz Anja,“ Streamlining Lo cal Behavior Through Communication,Incentives and Control: A Case Study of Lo cal Environmental Policies in China” ,Journal of Current Chinese Affairs,2011,3:77-112.
[28]Holmstrom,Bengt and Paul Milgrom,“ Multi-Task Principal-Agent Analyses: Linear Contracts,Asset Ownership and Job Design” ,Journal of Law,Economics and Organization,1991,7:24-52.
[29]Hardin,Garrett,“ The Tragedy of the Commons” ,Science,1968,62:1243-1248.
[30]Huang Yasheng,“Managing Chinese Bureaucrats: An Institutional Economics Perspective” ,Politi cal Studies,2002,50:69-74.
[31]Jackson,John E.(ed),Institution in American Society,Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press,1990,p.2.
[32]Jahiel,Abigail R.,“ The Organization of Environmental Protection in China” ,The China Quarterly(Special Issue: China' s Environment),1998,156: 757-787.
[33]John,Peter and HelenMargetts,“ Policy Punctuations in the UK: Fluctuations and Equilibria in Central Government Expenditure Since 1951” ,Public Administration,2003,81(3):441-432.
[34]Jones et al.,“ Policy Punctuation: U.S.Budget Authority,1947-1995” ,The Journal of Politics,1998,60(1):1-33.
[35]Jone,B.D.,Tracy Sulkin and H.A.Larsen,“ Policy Punctuations in American Politi cal Institutions” ,American Politi cal Science Review,2003,97(1):151-169.
[36]Jones,B.D.and F.R.Baumgartner,The Politics of Attention: How Government Prioritizes Problems,Chicago: University of Chicago Press,2005.
[37]Jones,B.D.,Reconceiving Decision-making in Democratic Politics.Attention,Choice,and Public Policy,Chicago: University of Chicago Press,1994.
[38]John,Peter,“ Is There Life after Policy Streams,Advocacy Coalition,and Punctuations: Using Evolutionary Theory to Explain Policy Change” ,Policy Studies Journal,2003,31(4):481-498.
[39]Jordan,Meagan M.,“ Punctuations and Agendas: A New look at lo cal government budget expenditures” ,Journal of Policy Analysis andManagement,2003,22(3):345-360.
[40]Kingdon,John,W.,Agenda,Alternatives,and Public Policies,Boston: Little Brown,1984.
[41]Kung,James Kai-Sing and Shuo Chen,“ The Tragedy of the Nomenklatura: Career Incentives and Politi cal Radi calism during China' s Great Leap Famine” ,American Politi cal Science Review,2011,105:27-45
[42]Landry,F.Pierre,Decentralized Authoritarianism in China: The Communist Party' s Control of Lo cal Elites in the Post-Mao Era,Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,2008.
[43]Lewis,Eugene,Public Entrepreneurship: Toward a Theory of Bureaucratic Politi cal Power,Bloomington: Indiana University Press,1980.
[44]Li Hongbin and Li-an Zhou,“ Politi cal Turnover and Economic Performance: The Incentive Role of Personnel Control in China” ,Journal of Public Economics,2005,89(9-10):1743-1762.
[45]Lieberthal Kenneth G.and David M.Lampton,Bureaucracy,Politics,and DecisionMaking in Post-Mao China,Berkeley:Oxford University Press,1992.
[46]Lieberthal,Kenneth G.“, China' s Governing System and Its Impact on Environmental Policy Implementation” ,China Environment Series,Washington,DC: Woodrow Wilson,1997.
[47]Lindblom,Charles E.,The Policy-making Process,Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall,1968.
[48]Margols,Howard,Patterns,Thinking,and Cognition,Chicago: University of Chicago Press,1987.
[49]Maria Edin,“ State Capacity and Lo cal Agent Control in China: CCP CadreManagement from a Township Perspective” ,The China Quarterly,2003,173:39.
[50]Mei Ciqi,Brings the politics back in: Politi cal incentive and policy distortion in China,Ph.D.Dissertation,The University ofMaryland,2009.
[51]Nancy C.Roberts,“ Public Entrepreneurship and Innovation” ,Policy Studies Review,1992,1(1): 55-63.
[52]Neisser,Ulric,Cognition and Reality,San Francisco: W.H.Freeman,1976.
[53]Merton,R.K.,Social Theory and Social Structure,New York: The Free Press,1968.
[54]Montinola et al.,“ Federalism,Chinese Style: The Politi cal Basis for Economic Success in China” ,World Politics,1995,48:50-81
[55]Mortensen,Peter B.,“ Policy Punctuations in Danish Lo cal Budgeting”,Public Administration,2005,83(4):931-950.
[56]Oates,W.E.,Fis cal Federalism,New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich,1972.
[57]Oi,Jean,“ Fis cal Reform and the Economic Foundations of Lo cal State Corporatism in China” ,World Politics,1992,45(1):99-126.
[58]Padgett,J.F.,“ManagingGarbage Can Hierarchies”,Administrative Science Quarterly,1980,25:583-604
[59]Padgett,J.F.,“ Bounded Rationality in Budgetary Research” ,The American Politi cal Science Review,1980,74:354-372.
[60]Pearce,David and Charles Palmer,“ Public and Private Spending for Environmental Protection: a Cross-country Policy Analysis” ,Fis cal Studies,2001,22(4):403-456.
[61]Portz,John,“ Problem Definitions and Policy Agendas: Shaping the Educational Agenda in Boston” ,Policy Studies Journal,1996,24:371-386.
[62]Qian,Yinyi and Weingast,B.R.,“ China' s Transition toMarkets:Market-preserving Federalism,Chinese Style” ,Journal of Economic Policy Reform,1996,1:149-185.
[63]Qian,Y.and G.Roland“, Federalism and the Soft Budget Constraint”,American Economic Review,1998,88(5):1143-1162.
[64]Rabe,Barry,Statehouse and Greenhouse: The Stealth Politics of America Climate Change Policy,Washington,DC: Brookings Institution Press,2006.
[65]Ran Ran,“ Perverse Incentive Structure and Policy ImplementationGap in China' s Lo cal Environmental Politics” ,Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning,2013,15(1):17-39.
[66]Redford,Emmette,Democracy in the Administrative State,New York: Oxford University Press,1969.
[67]Riker,William,The Art of Politi calManipulation,New Haven: Yale University Press,1986.
[68]Robinson,Scott E.,Floun' say Caver,Kenneth J.Meier and Laurence J.O' Toole,Jr.,“ Explaining Policy Punctuations: Bureaucratization and Budget Change” ,American Journal of Politi cal Science,2007,51(1): 140-150.
[69]Robinson,Scott E.and Caver,Flounsay.R.,“ Punctuated Equilibrium and Congressional budgeting” ,Politi cal Research Quarterly,2006,59(1):161-166.
[70]Robinson,Scott E.,“ Punctuated equilibriummodels in organizational decision making” ,In Goktug Morcol(ed.),Handbook of DecisionMaking,New York: CRC Taylor and Francis,2006.
[71]Ryu,Jay Eungha,“ Legislative Professionalism and Budget Punctuations in State Government Sub-Functional Expenditures” ,Public Budgeting and Finance,2011,31(2): 22-42.
[72]Schick,A.,The Capacity of Budget,Washington,D.C.: Urban Institute Press,1990.
[73]Schneider ,Mark and Paul Teske,“ Toward a Theory of the Politi cal Entrepreneur: Evidence fromLo cal Government” ,American Politi cal Science Review,1992,86(3):737-747.
[74]Silva,Emilson C.D.and Arthur J.Caplan,“ Transboundary pollution control in federal systems” ,Journal of Environmental Economics andManagement,1997 ,34:173–186.
[75]Simon,Herbert A.,“ The Logic of Heuristic Decision-Making” ,In R.S.Cohen,and M.W.Wartofsky.eds.,Modes of Discovery,Boston: D.Reidel,1977.
[76]Simon,Herbert,A.,“ Rational Decision-Making in Business Organization” ,American Economic Review,1979,69:495-501
[77]Simon,Herbert A.,Reason in Human Affairs,Stanford: Stanford University Press,1983.
[78]Simon,Herbert,A.,“ Human Nature in Politics: The Dialogue of Psychology with Politi cal Science” ,American Politi cal Science Review,1985,79: 293-304.
[79]Shah,A.,“ The Reform of Intergovernmental Fis cal Relations in Developing and EmergingMarket Economies” ,Policy Research Series Paper 23,Washington,DC: World Bank,1994.
[80]Spill,Rorie L,Michael J.Licari and Leonard J.Ray,“ Taking on Tobacco: Policy Entrepreneurship and the Tobacco Litigation” ,Politi cal Research Quarterly,2001,54(3):605-622.
[81]Steinmo,Sven,“ The New Institutionalism” ,in Barry Clark and Joe Foweraker,eds.,The Encyclopedia of Democratic Thought,London: Routldge,2001.
[82]Susan H.Whiting,Power and Wealth in Rural China: The Politi cal Economy of Institutional Change,Cambridge University Press,2006.
[83]Teodoro,Manuel,“ Bureaucratic Job Mobility and The diffusion of Innovations” ,American Journal of Politi cal Science,2009,53(1):175-189.
[84]Thelen,Kathleen and Sven Steinmo,“ Histori cal institutionalism in comparative politics” ,In Kathleen Thelen and Frank Longstreth,eds.,Structuring Politics: Histori cal Institutionalism in Comparative Analysis,Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,1992.
[85]Thorngate,Warren,“ On Paying Attention” ,in William J.Baker,L.P.Moos,and H.J.Stam,eds.,Recent Trends in Theoreti cal Psychology,New York: Springer-Verlag,1988.
[86]Tiebout C.M.,“ A Pure Theory of Lo cal Expenditures” ,Journal of Politi cal Economy,1956,64:416-424.
[87]Tony Saich,“ The BlindMan and the Elephant: Analyzing the Lo cal State in China” ,In East Asian Capitalism: Conflicts,Growth and Crisis,ed.,Tomba,Luigi,Milano:Feltrinelli,2002.
[88]True,J.L.,“ Is the National Budget Controllable?” ,Public Budgeting and Finance,1995,15(2):18-32
[89]True,J.L.,Jones,B.D.and Baumgartner,F.R.,“ Punctuated equilibrium theory: Explaining stability and change in American Policymaking” ,In P.Sabatier(ed),Theories of the Policy Process,Boulder,CO: Westview Press,2009.
[90]True,J ames L.,“ Attention,Inertia,and Equity in the Social Security Program” ,Social Science,1999,9(4):571-596.
[91]True,J.L.,B.D Jones and F.R.Baumgartner,“ Punctuated-equilibrium Theory: Explaining Stability and Change in Public Policymaking” ,in Sabatier,P.A.(ed),Theory of the Policy Process,Boulder,CO: Westview Press,2007.
[92]Truman,David.B.,The Government Process,New York: Alfred Knopf,1951.
[93]Tsui,Kai-yuen and Youqing Wang,“ Between Separate Stoves and a Single Menu: Fis cal Decentralization in China” ,The China Quarterly,2004,177:79.
[94]Van Rooij Benjamin and Carlos Wing-Hung Lo.,“ Fragile Convergence: Understanding Variation in the Enforcement of China' s Industrial Pollution Law” ,Law&Policy,2010,32(1):14-37.
[95]Vermeer,Eduard B.,“ Industrial Pollution in China and Remedial Policies” ,The China Quarterly(Special Issue: China' s Environment),1998,156:952-985.
[96]Walder,Andrew ,“ Lo cal Governments as Industrial Firms” ,American Journal of Sociology,1995,101:263-301.
[97]Wang,H.C.and Liu,B.J.,“ Policymaking for environmental protection in China” ,In: M.B.McElory,C.P.Nielsen & P.Lydon(eds),Energizing China,Reconciling Environmental Protection and Economic Growth,Cambridge:M.A.Harvard University Press,1998.
[98]Wang,Xiaohu,“ Exploring Trends,Sources,and Causes of Environmental Funding: A Study of Florida Counties” ,Journal of EnvironmentalManagement,2011,92(11):2930-2938;
[99]Wanxin Li and Paul Higgins,“ Controlling Lo cal Environmental Performance: an analysis of three national environmental management programs in the context of regional disparities in China” ,Journal of Contemporary China,2013,22(81): 409-427.
[100]Wendy,Schiller Wendy,“ Senators as Policy Entrepreneurs: Using Bill Sponsorship to Shape Legislative Agenda” ,American Journal of Politi cal Science,1995,9(1):186-203.
[101]Williamson,Oliver E.,The Economic Institution of Capitalism,New York: Free Press,1985.
[102]Wood,B.D.,“ Federalism and Policy Responsiveness: The Clear Air Case” ,The Journal of Politics,1991,53:851-859.
[103]Wu,Jing et al.,“ Incentives and Outcomes: China' s Environmental Policy” ,NBER Working Paper No.18754,2013.http://www.nber.org/papers/w 18754
[104]Young Nam Cho,“ From Rubber Stamps to Iron Stamps: The Emergence of Chinese Lo cal People's Congresses as Supervisory Powerhouses” ,The China Quarterly,2002,171:724-740.
[105]Young Nam Cho,Lo cal People' s Congresses in China: Development and Transition,New York: Cambridge University Press,2008.
[106]Zahariadis,Nikolaos,“ The Multiple Streams Framework: Structure,Limitations,Prospects” ,in Paul A.Sabatier(ed),Theories of the Policy Process(2nd edition),Boulder,CO: Westview Press.2007.
[107]Zheng,Yongnian,De Facto Federalism in China: Reforms and Dynamics of Central-lo cal Relations(Series on Contemporary China),World Scientific Publishing,2007
[108]Zhou Xueguang,“ The Institutional Logic of Collusion among Lo cal Governments in China” ,Modern China,2010,36(1):58.
[109]Zhu,Xufeng,“ Strategy of Chinese policy entrepreneurs in the third sector: challenges of‘Techni cal Infeasibility' ” ,Policy Science,2008,41:315–334.
中文文献
图书
[1][美]曼瑟尔·奥尔森:《集体行动的逻辑》,陈郁等译,上海三联书店1995年版。
[2]曹康泰、王学军:《信访条例辅导读本》,中国法制出版社2005年版。
[3]国家环境保护总局、中共中央文献研究室:《新时期环境保护重要文献选编》,中央文献出版社、中国环境科学出版社2001年版。
[4]国家环境保局:《中国的环境保护事业:1981—1985》,中国环境科学出版社1999年版。
[5]《金华市人民代表大会志》编纂委员会:《金华市人民代表大会志》,浙江摄影出版社2011年版。
[6]康锦达、朱少凡:《天责:一个人大代表行使权力的震撼经历》,中国社会科学出版社2003年版。
[7]厉以宁:《中国的环境与可持续发展》,经济科学出版社2004年版。
[8][美]詹姆斯·马奇:《决策时如何产生的》,王元歌、章爱民译,机械工业出版社2007年版。
[9]《宁波市人民代表大会志》编纂委员会:《宁波市人民代表大会志》,中华书局2010年版。
[10][美]道格拉斯·诺斯:《经济史中的结构变迁》,陈郁、罗华平译,上海三联出版社1994年版。
[11]彭真:《彭真文选(1941—1990年)》,人民出版社1991年版。
[12]曲格平、彭近新主编:《环境觉醒:人类环境会议和中国第一次环境保护会议》,中国环境科版社2010年版。
[13]沈阳市人大常委会:《地方人大代表工作实践与探索》,中国民主法制出版2010年版。
[14]孙佑海:《超越环境“风暴”—中国环境资源保护立法研究》,中国法制出版社,2008年版。
[15][美]丹尼尔·史普博:《管制与市场》,余晖等译,上海三联书店2017年版。
[16]汤大华、毛寿龙、宁宇、薛亮:《市政府管理:廊坊市调查》,中国广播电视出版社1997年版。
[17][德]托马斯·海贝勒、[德]安雅·森茨:《沟通、激励和监控对地方行为的影响:中国地方环境政策的案例研究》,载于[德]托马斯·海贝勒等主编:《中国与德国的环境治理:比较的视角》,中央编译出版社2012年版。
[18]汪劲主编:《环保法治三十年:我们成功了吗?中国环保法治蓝皮书(1979—2010)》,北京大学出版社2011年版。
[19]王金南、曹东:《能源与环境》,中国环境科学出版社2004年版。
[20]王绍光、胡鞍钢:《中国国家能力报告》,辽宁人民出版社1993年版。
[21]徐世群、李尚志、刘朝兴等:《地方人大监督工作研究》,中国民主法制出版社2005年版。
[22]于莉:《省会城市预算过程的政治》,中央编译出版社2010年版。
[23]张坤民、王玉庆:《中国环境保护投资报告》,清华大学出版社1992年版。
[24]《中国环境保护行政二十年》编委会:《中国环境保护行政二十年》,中国环境科学出版社1994年版。
[25]中国环境与发展国际合作委员会:《给中国政府的环境与发展政策建议》,中国环境科学出版社2005年版。
[26]周黎安:《转型中的地方政府:官员激励和治理》,上海人民出版社2008年版。
[27]朱光磊:《当代中国政府过程》,天津人民出版社2006年版。
期刊
[28]曹正汉、史晋川:《中国地方政府应对市场化改革的策略:抓住经济发展的主动权:理论假说与案例验证》,《社会学研究》2009年第4期。
[29]陈斌等:《环保部门经费保障问题调研》,《环境保护》2006年第11B期。
[30]陈继清:《我国信访制度存在的问题及其完善措施》,《中国行政管理》2006年第 6 期。
[31]陈丹、唐茂华:《试论我国信访制度的困境与“脱困”—日本苦情制度对我国信访制度的启示》,《国家行政学院学报》2006年第 1 期。
[32]程金华:《中国行政纠纷解决的制度选择》,《中国社会科学》2009年第6期。
[33]程绪水:《流域机构在应对重大水污染事件中的责任》,《治淮》2006年第5 期。
[34]杜辉:《论制度逻辑框架下环境治理模式之转换》,《法商研究》2013年第1期。
[35]黄冬娅、杨大力:《考核式监管的运行与困境:基于主要污染物总量减排考核的分析》,《政治学研究》2016年第4期。
[36]邝艳华:《公共预算决策理论评述:理性主义、渐进主义和间断均衡》,《公共政策评论》2011年第4期。
[37]李万新,[美]埃里克·祖斯曼:《从意愿到行动:中国地方环保局的机构能力研究》,《环境科学研究》2006年第19期。
[38]马骏:《交易费用政治学:现状与前景》,《经济研究》2003年第1期。
[39]马骏、侯一麟:《中国省级预算中的非正式制度:一个交易费用框架》,《经济研究》2004年第10期。
[40]曲格平:《中国环境保护事业发展历程提要(续)》,《环境保护》1988年第4期。
[41]Schroeder,Larry and Naomi Aoki:《测量分权的挑战》,熊美娟译,《公共行政评论》2009年第2期。
[42]尚宏博:《论我国环保督查制度的完善》,《中国人口、资源与环境》2014年S 1期。
[43]唐皇凤:《价值冲突与权益均衡:县级人大监督制度创新的机理分析》,《公共管理学报》2011年第8期。
[44]王绍光:《中国公共政策议程设置的模式》,《中国社会科学》2006年第5期。
[45]王贤彬、张莉、徐现祥:《辖区经济增长绩效与省长省委书记晋升》,《经济社会体制比较》2011年第1期。
[46]王永钦等:《中国的大国发展道路—论分权式改革的得失》,《经济研究》2007年第1期。
[47]夏光:《增强环境保护部参与国家综合决策的能力》,《环境保护》2008年第4A期。
[48]阎坤、张立承:《中国县乡财政困境分析与对策研究》,《经济研究参考》2003年第90期。
[49]杨鹏:《中国环保为什么困难重重?》,(香港)《二十一世纪评论》2005年2月第87期。
[50]杨涛:《间断—平衡模型:长期政策变迁的非线性解释》,《甘肃行政学院学报》2011年第2期。
[51]杨展里、葛勇德:《以南通为例分析中国地方环境执政能力建设的问题与对策》,《环境科学研究》2006年第19卷增刊。
[52]于莉:《预算过程:从渐进主义到间断式平衡》,《武汉大学学报》(哲学社会科学版)2010年第6期。
[53]周飞舟:《分税制十年:制度及其影响》,《中国社会科学》2006年第6期。
[54]周黎安:《晋升博弈中政府官员的激励与合作—兼论我国地方保护主义和重复建设问题长期存在的原因》,《经济研究》2004年第6期。
[55]周雪光:《“逆向软预算约束”:一个政府行为的组织分析》,《中国社会科学》2005年第2期。
[56]周雪光、练宏:《政府内部上下级部门间谈判的一个分析模型—以环境政策实施为例》,《中国社会科学》2011年第5期。
论文
[57]马骏、牛美丽:《重构中国公共预算体》(工作论文),2006年。
办法、规定与通知
[58]《中共中央组织部关于调整环境保护部门干部管理体制有关问题的通知》(组通字〔1999〕935号)
[59]《广东省市厅级党政领导班子和领导干部落实科学发展观评价指标体系及考核评价试行办法》
[60]《排污费征收使用管理条例》(国务院令〔2003〕第369号)和《关于环保部门实行收支两条线管理后经费安排的实施办法》
[61]财政部条法司编:《关于编报2007年财政预算的通知》,《中华人民共和国财政法规汇编(2006年7月—2006年12月)中册》,中国财政经济出版社2007年版。
置顶
版权所有:世界中国学研究联合会